Top 5 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Shoes on the Market (Updated 2018)

You will not even believe they are Steel Toe!

So you want to know about the most comfortable steel toe shoes on the market. They need to be able to be comfortable in Sneakers, but also have the security of a steel toe boot.

Job sites require you to be active, but that doesn’t mean you should compromise comfort for safety. Here are the top 5 steel toe shoes out there today. Happy walking!

New Balance Men's MID627 Steel-Toe Work ShoeA++$$-$$$
Skechers for Work Men’s Soft Stride Steel Toe Work ShoeA
Timberland PRO Men’s 40008 Mudsill Low Steel Toe Lace UpA+$$-$$$
Keen Utility Men’s Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work ShoeA+$$-$$$
Skechers Sports Men’s Afterburn Memory Foam Lace up SneakerA$$-$$

How To Choose The Most Comfortable Steel Toe Shoes?

Make sure you have your correct shoe size. Some product vary, so checks websites to see if the shoe runs big or small, wide or narrow. This will help to ensure you have the perfect fit.

Check for insoles: 

Sometimes they have removable insoles, or sometimes the shoes needed additional insoles for support. In both ways, it is a good idea to have a comfortable pair of orthotics if you are going to be spending numerous hours on your feet.

Check reviews and read what others have to say about the shoe.

Did they find them comfortable or what do they recommend if not? Yes, we all have different sized and shaped feet, but if numerous people report the same negative point about a shoe, then you know it is bad.

Try them on.

This is the most obvious point, but most often people forget to do. If you are searching for the best buy online, then that is fine, but go into the store and try the shoe on before purchasing it. Then you will know if you are more likely to wear it or not.

What Are The Interests And Benefits Of This Product?

The steel toe is a safety device for added protection in your shoe. You can work on construction sites and shipyards with security and satisfaction that your feet will be left unharmed.

Shoes will allow you to be quicker on your feet and allow you to have more flexibility in the soles your shoes as compared to boots.

When you have the security of a steel toe and the comfort of a sneaker, you have one of the best footwear out there for the hardworking man.

Read more: How to Choose the Best Black Friday Work Boots for Men

Things To Look For And Attributes That Differentiate These Products:

A Steel Toe

These shoes should all have a steel toe for added safety and protection when on a work site. The steel toe will protect you from any mishandlings and mishaps that may happen with sharp tools and welding.You can see test of steel toe cap shoes:

A Rubber Sole

This will help to keep them slip-proof and have better traction. It also offers a bit more support for your legs and feet. As a bonus, the rubber sole helps protect you from electric shock that may happen on a work site.

That is something you should not take for granted!

A Good Arch And Insoles

If you are going to be on your feet for extended periods of time, it needs to be with a ideal insole and high arches. Some have insoles you can take out and then you can put your own in if you require more comfort and support.

Also, the right arches will help with back support and it also helps you be on your feet longer.

Leather Shoes

These are a must. These shoes can be worn in all types of weather and are also waterproof or water resistant. They are more durable and will last longer as compared to a canvas shoe or ones made of fake leather.


Most websites will say if the fit is as expected or not. I would look for one that is around 80% or higher just so you know if you need to buy larger or smaller, wider or narrower. Being stuck with a shoe that does not fit properly (and may not be returnable if you wore it outside) is just miserable.

What Is The Best Way To Use Steel Toe Shoes?


These are most suitable for a large worksite. They are comfortable with a flexible sole and heel so you can run from site to site. The steel toe is perfect for added protection, but I would not advise you to drop something heavy or sharp intentionally on your shoe to see if it works.

Day To Day Activities

You can use them to do housework, mow the lawn, different chores, and just casual walks or even a run. They can be utilized the same way that sneakers are used, just with the bonus of a steel toe. You need the best shoes for walking all day , which should still be lightweight enough where doing these daily tasks should not be an issue to the wearer.

Top 5 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Shoe Recommendation On The Market

New Balance Men's MID627 Steel-Toe Work ShoeA++$$-$$$
Skechers for Work Men’s Soft Stride Steel Toe Work ShoeA
Timberland PRO Men’s 40008 Mudsill Low Steel Toe Lace UpA+$$-$$$
Keen Utility Men’s Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work ShoeA+$$-$$$
Skechers Sports Men’s Afterburn Memory Foam Lace up SneakerA$$-$$

New Balance sneakers are known around the world as carefully constructed comfortable sneakers that will last for years to come. They are both athletic and casual, but the steel toe adds the extra bonus of being perfect for the workplace.

New Balance Men’s MID627 Steel Toe Work Shoe

When people see the NB on your steel toe shoe, they know that you mean business. They have great support from comfortable insoles and arches. New Balance shoes always run true to size, and if not people selling them will be honest and tell you if they are not.

These are my personal favorite brand of sneakers you can purchase. Add the steel toe to them and I would even work on a production site or shipyard so that I can have an excuse to wear New Balance sneakers to work.

What We Like

  • They only weigh 4 pounds
  • They are just as durable and comfortable as a pair of running sneakers by the same brand
  • They come in Extra Wide (E)
  • People believe that the quality has increased, while the price has decreased if that is even possible
  • They come in a narrow width
  • Ideal for working on concrete

What We Don't Like

  • Some report the sole starting to split around six months
  • Some believe that the width is not accurate, but the shoe size is.

Skechers for Work Men's 76760 Soft Stride Steel-Toe Work Shoe

These shoes are made of leather with a rubber sole to help with absorbing shock. They have shoe laces along with a padded collar and steel toe. They also offer the all-great slip resistant outsole. These shoes run true to size and are made or durable leather.

When a shoe is endorsed by Chevron Houston Marathon for their athletes, you know it is good enough for you and your worksite. They provide comfort and reliability everyone is looking for in a sneaker, but now with an extra steel toe for safety.

What We Like

  • Come in Extra Wide
  • Great when working on lumber yards and as a contractor
  • Long lasting
  • Run true to size

What We Don't Like

  • Some believe the quality is going down
  • Toe is quite narrow
  • They are said to be slip resistant, but many report them to be very slippery on tile floor

These shoes are made of leather with a rubber sole. The steel toe is to help with work sites and absorb shock. They are designed for 24/7 comfort and support.

They are made by Timberland, which is well known for their work boots so that you will find a solid pair of work shoes by them as well.

Timberland PRO Men's 40008 Mudsill Low Steel-Toe Lace-Up

The timberland PRO men’s low steel lace up is a new work boot which brings toughness of a work boot incorporated in a comfortable sneaker that can be worn in the streets. The boot features high quality breathability and flexibility combined with exquisite fabric to give your feet safety and protection from harmful objects.

Timberland mudsill is a rugged multipurpose steel toe boot and the EVA midsole provide lightweight support and abrasion resistant features.

What We Like

  • Run true to size
  • Perhaps the highest rating you can find on the internet
  • They are lightweight and have a great support system built in
  • They are resistant to oil and abrasions which are ideal for those in construction and shipyards
  • Will last for about a year

What We Don't Like

  • Very thin insole
  • The insides are not well constructed

Made of leather and has a rubber sole. The heel is about 1.25” thick. They are both oil and slip resistant with a remarkable no marking rubber outsole.

Keen is known for their lightweight, yet supportive shoes and these are no different from their other work shoes.

Keen Utility Men’s Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe

The 1006977 KEEN Men's Atlanta Cool Safety Shoes brings in a new dimension in framing, and in jobs, which little airflow is involved. The boots are light with breathable mesh and sturdy steel toe protection.

The Atlanta cool steel toe boots are comfortable on the job and they can be worn from the mountains, beaches and in the city streets. With the protective mesh your feet are protected from harmful bacteria and fungi moreover, the reflective webbing allows easy removal and a stable shoe to work with.

What We Like

  • Weighs only 3 pounds
  • Come in extra wide sizes
  • Great comfortable and regular shoes if you are working over 40 hours a week
  • The lightest steel toe out there

What We Don't Like

  • Some report that the shoe is not worth the price tag. Comfortable, but not that comfortable

These shoes are made of both leather and synthetic materials. They have a rubber sole with is perfect for absorbing shock on the work site.

The heel is about 2 inches thick, and the memory foam insole is removable if you desire.

Skechers Sport Men's Afterburn Memory-Foam Lace-Up Sneaker

Skechers afterbun is crafted with modern mesh fabric, smooth leather, and synthetic material, which makes the shoe lighter while providing ultimate protection. The boot features a reinforced overlay, which provides comfort and protection.

The perforation on the front and the back is essential for providing airflow and this in turn prevents build up of bacteria and fungi on the feet. Skechers is an award winning shoe manufacturer and since its inception, high quality and comfort are the features that drive the shoe manufacturers.

What We Like

  • A fashion sneaker that is perfect for work
  • Come in extra wide
  • The insole feels like a cloud

What We Don't Like

  • Poor quality,the downside is that they break after a short time and have a high propensity of getting wet


Some of the top brands of steel toe shoes listed above are the best in the market. After identifying your budget and preference, you can never go wrong if you choose one of them.​

Of course, I have chosen the New Balance shoes to be the most comfortable steel toe shoe. They are quality made and light weight. Anyone who has not worn New Balance has an excuse to try a pair on. You may need them for work someday.

Sara Smith

My name is Sara Smith, the proud owner of the blog and the writer of all the articles that you can see on this website. It is my goal to share my knowledge to all of you and to provide valuable learnings in one way or another.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 1 comments